Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Why Even Have Kids? A Father's Day Reflection

RATE: 9



I always knew I wanted kids.  Two, to be exact.  At least I think I always felt that way.  I'm told that I once said to my mom that I'd never get married and have kids, but I was probably just trying to annoy her.
Shortly after I was married I told a friend that I hoped to  start the kid route in the near future.  She had observed me smiling the kids running around the coffee shop and begun to inquire about my plans.
"Why?" she asked.  Not rhetorically, but she genuinely wanted to know.
Why indeed?
You'd think it would be an easy question, but sometimes it's hard to explain the rationale for something you always just assumed.
In the pre-effective birth control world, children were just assumed--unless you weren't going to have any sex.  Without artificial birth control, the average woman having regular sex during her reproductive years would get pregnant an astonishing 13 times!
The Pill recently turned 50 years old.  Even so, having kids is by and large the assumption of most people still today.  Now we're able to be thoughtful on number of kids and timing.  The impacts of this revolution have been extensive and astounding.  Most couples are still having at least one kid though.
Some people question whether they want to have kids altogether.  If only more of us asked the question, "Do I want to have kids at all? If so, why?"  I'm sure most of us can think of specific people we wish would have decided that kids really weren't for them.
I don't recall how I answered her question. I think I said something to the effect of how much I enjoyed kids, that I felt I had a lot I could teach and instill in a child of mine, that I thought I'd be a good parent, that despite my cynical outer shell I was essentially an optimist whose contribution to this wonderful world could include healthy, smart, joyful, caring children.

I knew parenthood would be difficult.  Goddamnit! It has been difficult! It's been difficult despite the fact that I only have two kids, they are not problem kids, I have a full parenting partner, and we haven't had any family traumas.  It's still hard!
Plus, I've just gotten started.  I have another 15 years minimum until they are out of the house.
I knew parenthood would be joyful.  Goddamnit.  It has been incredibly joyful!  To have a daughter of mine who reads Encyclopedia Brown with a flashlight late into the night.  To have another clever and confident daughter who laughs at my dumb, silly antics.  Even though she is just three, she knows when anyone in her family needs a hug.
I don't want anything special for Father's Day. I just want my girls to be their regular playful, curious, compassionate selves.  I'm proud of them and want them to just be.  If I'm allowed to take just 5% credit to how they are turning out, that's enough pride for me and enough of a present.
So if the missus reads this, I don't need anything on Sunday.  Let's just have some fun as a family.
(Though perhaps a beer and a little quiet time would be nice too...)

CommentS
I have 2 girls as well. They're in their 20s and don't laugh at my silly antics anymore. But my dog finds me amusing.
john blumenthal
I had my only daughter rather late in life. I waited or didn't have one earlier because I hadn't found the man who would be the father I needed. Or rather, I worried that I'd be a great dad, but I needed the man to be the great mom. Didn't work out the way I planned and good to see you have the happy family and that your daughters are such a joy. I'll only add: Why did no one ever tell me that one never should have only one? Tis true.

Anyway, it was a great adventure if not the adventure I imagined. And two is so right, I think only children have a harder time, w/too much attention, too little cushion from we adults who love them. You're one lucky dad. Every day sounds like Father's Day... Rated
wendyo
I didn't know that I wanted to be a parent until I got with someone who had the most amazing kid. I married her, and I wouldn't trade either of them for anything in the world.
Owl_Says_Who
It's a good thing for the human race that we have kids when we're young and stupid. It's the only way we can be brave enough to do it.

My youngest is 26 and I can look back and say "Yeah, it really was all worth it." but if I'd known what was getting into, I doubt I'd have the courge to start.

Happily, life only happens to you a day at a time. And, trust me, you can do anything for a day.
John Leonard
Great post and agree with your reasons for having kids. Have our only, lost a first pregnancy or we might have had 2 which I agree is a better number.
o'stephanie

Monday, June 14, 2010

I want to live somewhere else!

RATE: 11



When I was in middle school I read a survey that most of my peers wanted to live within 50 miles of where they grew up.  This surprised me.  Didn't they want to escape just like me?
I did my own survey of my friends.  Every single one wanted to stay in northeastern Wisconsin. Astonishing!  Why?
In college I had dreams of spending years abroad.  I traveled some at the time and that desire only grew.  I figured that's how I'd live my 20s.  In my 30s I'd probably settle down in San Francisco, Seattle or Washington, DC. Definitely not the Midwest.  Then, I'd settle down and get married.
Right out of college, I moved to DC. A bit backwards plan-wise, but still a good start.
Then I got married.
Then I moved back to the Midwest.
Then I had kids.
So now I'm here for a bit.  More than 1000 miles from an ocean. Definitely not in Europe, the Middle East, or any other neat foreign place.
At least I don't live in the same town I grew up in.  I'm almost 300 miles away!


Why do we live the places we do? For most of us it's determined by a combination of jobs, affordability and proximity to family.  Indeed, there are times I wish I lived in the same town as my kids' grandparents.
Driving out this month to Wyoming and Montana made me jealous of the Western lifestyle--at least the lifestyle I was exposed to in the tourist towns.  Everything was beautiful.  People were so friendly.  Nevermind there are no jobs, I'd be far away from my family, or the different cultural and political values I'd have from my new hypothetical neighbors.  I would be near mountains!
Sigh...
I love my home. I love my neighbors. I love my city. I'll love my state even more once we get rid of the governor this January.  But sometimes I grow envious.  Is the grass greener on the other side of the continental divide?

When I was 10 and my sister bet me $5 that she'd leave Wisconsin before me.  At the time she hated the place.  That was 22 years ago.  Today she's still there, although now on the other side of the river.  I'm still waiting for my $5 in the exotic Land of 10,000 Lakes.

Comments

I think about this all the time. I wish I lived on the coast by the ocean or in the desert Southwest. I live in the Central Valley, here for my husband's tenured position. Maybe we'll retire somewhere beautiful. This was a thoughtful post. r
Maureenow
Derek, people talking about where they live and why they picked that location is a subject that I find no end of fascination to. That's funny that you bet your sister about who would leave the state first!

A number of my classmates from high school cleared out of the town where I live north of NYC. I looked around and saw more reasons to continue to call this home than to move elsewhere. It's a bucolic area where people from the city like to have country homes and it's quite close to the city. Long Island Sound, while lacking in the rougher surf of the ocean, is about a 45 minute drive from here.
designanator
You asked, "Is the grass greener on the other side of the continental divide?" I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but yes it is. It most certainly is. Just ask Elizabeth Gilbert.
marytkelly
...and here I have been keeping in mind how beautifully green I found WI last time we drove through....and I love the barns out your way--- with the stone foundations... I want to live in one! (refurbished interior of course)...
Just Thinking...
We have no choice where we are born, and I think little choice in where we end up.....xoxoxox
Robin Sneed
NYC born & raised, i spent the first 20 or so years of my life there. it was a great place to be 20 something & single.

the next 20or so were spent in the mid-west...Iowa mostly. i raised my children there...it was a great place to do that.

a couple of years ago i moved to the west coast...first to the beach, now in the desert... so far, its my favorite place to live.
lorianne
skeptic, I hated my home town growing up and swore to get out and never come back. Yet... post marriage, post kids, here I am. It takes more character to be able to return to where you came from, especially if you weren't so happy with it in the first place.

Remember, wherever you go, there you are... you can run, but you can't hide.
Grace Hwang Lynch
I'm fortunate in that I had the opportunity to live in several different places earlier in my life, including overseas. I'm still rather astonished that I ended up in a small industrial city in the Midwest. I never would have dreamed I would spend the bulk of my adulthood raising a family here.

That being said, I'm a firm believer that where you live is a very minor determinant for one's happiness. If a person is unhappy, geography is not the reason for it.
Procopius
I moved as far away from my mother as humanly possible without leaving the continental US. So I'm one of those who left and never looked back!
teendoc
Maureenow: central valley still sounds nice. I bet the winters are alright.
Designat: proximity to city and ocean: very nice.
Ame: family is indeed key.
Mary t k: I knew it!
Just: the barns are pretty, but would you really want to live in one? Think about the mounds of cow dung that have passed thru those old buildings over the years.
Robin: we have a choice, we just forget sometimes about all the constraints on those choices.

Lorianne: I think I'd love the desert except for the part with the poisonous snakes.
Skeptic Turtle
I've lived in many places from New England to Arizona, Pennsylvania, San Diego, Texas, and S Florida, and several short-term places in between.

But if I'd gone the family route, I would have likely ended up closer to home and to family back in Mass to raise kids.

I am permanently settled in South Florida now, because it's the spot I like the best!
Kellylark
Grace: sometimes one would prefer not to build character, but I see your point.
Procopious: I think I could be happy just about anywhere, even northern Illinios. But I'd always think there was somewhere better (with mountains)!
Teendoc: I understand why it 'd desirable for some to get away. For me, being within a shrt day
hv
Skeptic Turtle
Kelly: there's something for everyone, but I just don't get why people choose to live in south Florida.
Skeptic Turtle
With all that oil gushing, being far from the ocean may turn out not to be such a bad thing. Also, I think a lot of our modern mobility has to do with the fickle nature of modern jobs. People sometimes have to move a great distance to find work. Some might say they “are able to” as if this were mostly a positive. But I'm not so sure it is. I have a post I've been meaning to write ont his topic. Maybe I'll get to it one of these days. Meanwhile, thanks for an interesting time out from the more pressing matters of the day. Good luck collecting your due.
Kent Pitman
My Lutheran Wisconsin relatives might answer that way!
I do dream a bit...
Just Thinking...
You are soooo not alone in this thought. For me, I miss the beaches of Lake Michigan . . .
Owl_Says_Who
wow, this article is so true, i really feel the same way, I always want to live in another place, I have the feeling that I can become more happy over there... When I see people living in the same town their whole life, I think 'why do they do that?'. It's just safe, but I hope I will never chose for the regular options in life.
lisalisalisa

Friday, May 14, 2010

Ding! Dong! The Tooth Fairy's dead!

RATE: 26  EDITOR’S PICK

My six year old lost her third tooth this spring.  She pulled it out before breakfast after I told her that her friend had that very same tooth accidentally kicked out by a brother the night before.  (It had been loose.) My daughter didn't want to be left behind and twisted the loose bugger out.  She bled some, but blood and pain have never really bothered her.
That night it was time for the Tooth Fairy.  We remind her matter-of-factly to put her tooth under her pillow.  While I help her little sister brush her teeth, the six year old tells her mom that she "doesn't believe that the Tooth Fairy exists."
"Why do you say that?"
"Because the Tooth Fairy is magic and I don't believe that magic is real."
At this point a parent has two options: Come clean or double down and convince her the Tooth Fairy is real.  As skeptics hoping to inspire skepticism in our own children, the wife chooses Door Number One.
"Who do you think takes your tooth then?"
Our daughter is actually puzzled by this, she hadn't thought it out that far.  After a moment she reads her mom's expression.
"You? Do you take my teeth?"
"Yes. Well, actually your dad does it."
"Why?"
"Because your dad and I are excited for you for losing your baby teeth and it's a fun way to celebrate it."
I enter the room as she asks our daughter not to spoil the fun by telling her classmates.  Frankly, I could care less if she told some kids, but I don't want their parents coming after me.  Evidentally, the mother of a childhood friend of mine still blames me for telling her son the "truth" about Santa Claus (even though I didn't).
I posted this development on Facebook as an end to an era.  A couple of friends, one with kids, one without, expressed deep sadness.  That the end of childhood magic was a profound loss.
I'm not sad at all. I don't want to infantilize my children.  They should be encouraged to think for themselves and question the world as presented to them.  It was fine to have the Tooth Fairy fantasy for a bit (some hard-core skeptics and atheists would reject those completely), but things run their course.
One friend lamented the loss of magic and wrote "I hope she will soon learn that magic can indeed exist, but in different ways."
I hope that too, though I wouldn't use the word magic.  The world has enough real life mystery and wonders to provoke our imaginations.  We can enjoy fictional fantasies too without believing they are real.
My daughter is interested in nature and science.  There will always be mysteries in our universe to ponder over and solve.  Even though she is a very literal minded kid, her favorite book right now is Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, a fantastical, quite unbelievable story.
I have at times tried to shelter my kids from reality.  I turn off the news when stories of mass bombings in Iraq surface.  But kids aren't dumb and can figure things out. They ask questions and we shouldn't fear answering them. Why try to stunt their development?
When I was five, I believe most of my peers were told that babies came storks or hospitals.  My mom felt she should just tell me the truth.  I escaped trauma.  I don't think many five year olds today are given the stork explanation, but we still seem to have a lot of ways we keep our kids in a cloud of ignorance.
We found ourselves telling our six year old about sex when a dinnertime conversation went from how many bones are in the body, to what is the pelvis, to what is the uterus, to how does the sperm from the father actually "get" inside the mother anyways?
When tooth number four came out last week, she was excited to clean it off, put it under the pillow, and discover a gold coin the next morning.  Less mysterious, but still "magical" and fun!
She asked me what I did with her teeth.  I told her I save the teeth along with nail clippings to help create the Naglfar ship when Ragnarök dawns. In response to her puzzled look, I promised I'd tell her about the Norse myths sometime soon.

Comments
I went thru something similar with my son TJ, and at one point I forgot to put the money up for the tooth. The next night my son got a not and a dollar from Henry, Toothfairy #237, stating he had visited the night before and was unable to find the tooth since TJ had not put it under his pillow properly.
Tom Cordle
Oh, this is a bittersweet story for me to read. Though I want my kidlet to be equally reality based (forget princesses! We don't need someone with a penis to come rescue us! We can figure a way out our own damn selves!) there is still something so sweet and wondrous about childhood imagination, faith, and possibility. Its purity, its earnestness...qualities so beautiful and fragile, that I know I will mourn its loss.

Yet as you can tell from my most recent post, I'm in a pretty wispy place right now as the kidlet has just turned 3. Of course I want her to know the truths of life and not live in magical fantasyland. But I do admit to wanting to stop time and protecting the innocence and openheartedness for the onslaught of the world we live in.

Sigh...
teendoc
This is brilliant. I hope this serves as a lesson to you, and to everyone, that, while "magic" may not exist, there are reasons for our mythology. Even modern time mythology such as Star Trek and Star Wars reflect some of the great deeper lessons of humanity and our ability to expand our minds, and become "the hero" and take "the heros journey", even if that journey is only within one's own life.
Placebostudman
This is a magical post. In a good way. So many reminders of our own childhoods merge with our children's. I like --and am not surprised-- that you too use correct terms for body parts. Oprah, et al have done serious damage with "va-jay-jay." I can't wait to hear your next stories.
Sally Swift
Thanks all for your kind words.

Teendoc, I hear you. It's certainly a tension between wanting them to learn about and being part of the world and protecting them from the cynicism of us adults. Even at three years old. I see the job as a parent as both equipping our kids to be responsible and well functioning people, as well as equipping them to see life as a wonderful and happy thing. Easier said than done.
Skeptic Turtle
The Hel you say. Bwa ha ha ha ha.
ocularnervosa
Love this. You make many great points.
1_Irritated_Mother
Great essay! Like your son, I figured out very young that the Tooth Fairy=Mom and Dad. (Ditto, Santa.) My life has been no poorer for this; over the years, I've learned that real life holds its own magic if you care to look for it. I'm sure your son will be fortunate enough to learn this too!
Felicia Lee
This is lovely. I claimed to believe in the tooth fairy right up until fourth grade, but that's because I was greedy. I would have stuck my wisdom teeth under a pillow, if I'd been able to take them home.
Mrs. Michaels
To be perfectly honest, as much as I enjoyed believing that Tooth Fairies, Easter Bunnies and Santa Claus were real, I was pretty confused by the fact that my parents had been lying to me. It just didn't make sense that I would be punished for not telling the truth, but they deliberately told lies. I still don't know how to think about the myths. I did, however, continue the tradition with my son.
L in the Southeast
Loved the last paragraph, too funny. Not having kids freed me from most of the more delicate decisions in life. I think it would be hard to have to consciously mold someone else, but at the same time know that if you don't, it's going to happen anyway.
hyblaean- Julie
I hope she's always curious and amazed. There's enough incredible in the world that we really don't need fairy tales. rated
sueinaz
Great post, Turtle! Your daughter is obviously thinking for herself and not to be easily hoodwinked.

We never had any tooth fairies at my house when I was a kid. Too many kids, and not enough coins. But I still remember when I first realized that SAnta Claus wasn't real. A kid in my second grade class told the teacher, who was my mother, "I know who Santa Claus is. It's your father." I was standing right there, and I remember thinking, "Yeah, that makes sense." So I think I wasn't a real believer anyway, but just sort of went along with the game and enjoyed the toys. And tolerated the clothes.

There are mysteries enough in the real world to marvel at, as you say. And it seems to me that setting children up for a heart breaking discovery that they've been lied to is setting the parents up to lose their childrens trust, and all for the sake of perpetuating something that isn't real in the first place.
HenryR
Your daughter sounds like a girl after my own heart. I was never a big believer in magic but I'm still caught off-guard by the wonders of the world.

My mother saved all my baby teeth. I have them in a little pill bottle. It's amazing to hold these tiny hard bits of me that I made myself so many years ago. I think the mystery of that far outweighs the loss of the pretend magic of the Tooth Fairy.

Good for you and your wife for respecting your daughter's perspective of the world and answering her questions truthfully as they arise. And for saving room for the enchantment of myths and fantasies as well.
ixxidust
This is a sweet piece, ST. I've always had a hard time with the made-up childhood rituals. Now my kids are all beyond the Tooth Fairy and Santa Claus years and it suits me fine. I no longer have to keep up the myths. I'm not a very good liar so this is welcome news for me.

I agree with you; there's plenty of magic and wonder in real life. No need to invent it.
Lisa Kern
Truthiness does in the tooth fairy? =o)

Your daughter is very sensible. I do think though that children really love a cool, inexplicable surprise, even if they know Mom and Dad are really the ones in charge of producing them. My nephew knew there was no Santa, but every Christmas morning, my brother and sister in law had some surprise waiting for him in the morning that hadn't been there when he went to bed. It was fun, Nathan loved the surprises, and Alan and Linda loved planning them.
Shiral
I wonder if some gay dentist might adopt the title for commercial purposes.
Jan Sand
There is so much fun and surprise when we pretend. We still believe in Santa claus at our house. My kids are22, 21 and 16
utopia77
You are the only person besides Richard Heinlien that I have seen use Ragnorak in a sentence. What a cool dad you are, D.
SFine really
The toothfairy may die, but it's never too soon to teach the Eddas!
Poppi Iceland
My daughter came into my room one morning (she was 5) and said "Mom, you didn't pay me for my tooth last night". I asked "What tooth?" and she filled me in on the one she had knocked out on the trampoline the day before, an incident she'd been afraid to tell me about. Then she informed me she had figured out there wasn't a tooth fairy when it was still under the pillow that morning, but she certainly wanted to be paid for her trouble! She felt a dollar would be fine. (she's still funny and still knows what she wants)
Gabby Abby
Gab. Ab., sounds like your daughter is quite a negotiator!
Skeptic Turtle
I often think of the Arthur C. Clark quote, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."

I remember being amused when my son declared that obviously the Easter Bunny was fake - while never doubting Santa Claus. Now (a few years later) he enjoys being the Big Kid who knows the secrets behind the magic. I didn't have a Santa experience when I was a child, but as a parent I don't feel that it's not magical. What's more unlikely: That Santa would exist? Or that 100 million adults would conspire to make his deeds come true? Seems kind of "indistinguishable" to me.
wildmarjoram
I notice a preponderance of white Liberals here. Curious.
Jack Blair
Skeptic, this is a wonderful essay that raises the possibilities of healthy conversations between kids. If you have eavsdropped, as many parents have, on conversations between kids, the exchanges are suprisingly complex at times, with their active minds exploring myth and plausibility. I agree about the active role of "fiction" in their lives. It is incredibly important.
Gary Justis
Jack, don't know what you're getting at, or whether you're referring to comments on this post or Open Salon in general.
Skeptic Turtle