Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Happy Tax Day

Happy tax day! It is an as good a day as any other to reflect that we are one country, pooling our hard-earned money for the general and greater good.

What's that? Where do we spend our hard-earned tax dollars? Well, for lots of things of course! The biggest one just happens to be war. For fiscal year 2009, expenditures for past, present, and future war actions account for 54 cents on the dollar. Makes you feel good inside.



Courtesy of the War Resisters League. They explain their methodology here.

Expelled coming your way

Ben Stein's anti-science film, Expelled, will be in theaters nationwide this Friday, April 18. Since I wrote about this last week, the National Center for Science Education has unveiled their website Expelled Exposed. The site refutes the nonsense presented in the film as well as questions the examples of intelligent design martyrs.


While questioning whether people were really "expelled" for their openness to intelligent design, they provide at least one example of someone fired for not being "neutral" in the scientific "debate" between evolution and intelligent design.




MORE RESPONSES FROM THE SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY

Eugenie Scott, the director of the National Center for Science Education, was "bamboozled" (her word) into participating in the film. She is interviewed by Scientific American writer, Steve Mirsky, in his weekly podcast. The podcast also has an interview with Scientific American editor-in-chief, John Rennie, on his views after being shown the film by one of the associate producers.

Scientific American recorded the discussion between the producer and staff members after being shown the film. I'm not patient enough to listen to the hour-long discussion, but it was reportedly "energetic." Listen to it here.

Skeptic writer Michael Shermer also appears in the film and wrote about his experience and impressions in a recent column. He looks at the big and small ways the film deceives, including hiring extras for a scene at Pepperdine University when they couldn't recruit enough supporting students.

It looks like the scientific community is taking this film seriously.

The few film reviewers that have been permitted to see (or snuck into) a screening, haven't regarded it highly either.

Monday, April 14, 2008

A little worse than "monkeys"

Republican congressman, Geoff Davis, put the recent mini-controversy over a Democratic convention delegate referring to kids climbing a tree as "monkeys" into perspective.

Rep. Davis talked about participating in a "highly classified, national security simulation” with Sen. Barack Obama.

Davis went on to say:

“I'm going to tell you something: That boy's finger does not need to be on the button. He could not make a decision in that simulation that related to a nuclear threat to this country.”


Yes. Davis called Obama a "boy." Davis did have the wisdom to apologize quickly after the Obama campaign took him to task.

via Pol Watchers


Changing the presidential primary process

When I was 18 years old, I visited a prospective college and interviewed for a scholarship. A panel that included a current student and a professor talked to me for about 20 minutes. The professor, upon hearing I was interested in politics asked me how I thought the presidential primary system should be reformed. The criticism being the unfairness that some small, unrepresentative states had disproportionate say.

I can't remember my exact response, but I think it boiled down to I have idea in the world. I didn't get the scholarship.

Now over a decade later, having studied political science in college, and worked in politics for seven years, I still am unsure how to answer that question.

I'm amazed that for all the talk about the process this year and how it works and doesn't work, there seems to have been only a little discussion on how to actually fix it for next time. And once this election season is behind us, this will all become a distant memory and people won't have the fire under them to change things for 2012 in any substantive way. Remember during the 2000 election mess all the talk about reforming or doing away with the electoral college? I remember bold predictions that the electoral college would be gone before 2004. Fat chance at that.

One hopes that both Democrat and Republican elites understand that change needs to happen. The Republicans didn't get too burned this time, but it could almost as easily been them with two candidates threatening to go all the way to the convention. The only "advantage" the Republicans have in this respect is the existence of some winner-takes-all primaries that serve to prop up the candidate in the lead. Despite some arguments from Clinton supporters, the Democrats should not emulate the undemocratic electoral college in their candidate selection process.

Who can say what should be done then? There are alternative plans out there to make it more orderly. But first, maybe some guiding principles.

  • Democracy should be valued in this process. Having a presumptive nominee before half the country has voted is undemocratic. The most obvious solution would be in part to have a more condensed season.
  • Less populous states shouldn't get overwhelming disproportionate say in the candidates. Still, efforts should be made to give some protection to smaller states and rural constituencies in general.
  • The process should at least make sense to voters.

Plans have been proposed to put states into regional groups or non-regional groups (either randomly or by relative size) and then having the primary season spaced out over several months between the regions/groups. In some plans the regions/groups would be in the same order each time and other plans suggest a rotation in order or lottery. Political scientist Larry Sabato suggests a regional approach with a lottery on January 1 of the election year to determine the order of regions, preventing candidates from camping in the early states for the previous 12 months. (Or in John Edwards' case, 36 months.)

The main weakness in many of the proposals is that it puts up further roadblocks against second-tier candidates being able to use grassroots organizing to be made into contenders. The argument is that it makes money all important. Frankly, I don't know if that changes much between the status quo and these plans. A candidate will always need lots of money to compete, but I don't think there is strong evidence that one can buy their way to the White House.

All plans still require immense grassroots organizing, aside from possibly the idea of a national primary, which is politically unrealistic anyways.

I think the rotating regional primary makes the most sense. The plan wouldn't necessarily put 1/4 of the country on the same date, but on the same month. Region 1 states could have their contests as early as the first Tuesday of March. Many would go on the first Tuesday, but some might take the lesson from this year and realize that earlier isn't necessarily better, especially on a crowded day.

One variation favored by the National Association of Secretaries of State shown on the right, maintains an exception for the early Iowa caucuses and New Hampshire primary, to occur in February. Personally, I think that would be fine, although maybe in the long term the Iowa and New Hampshire exceptions should be eliminated.

My main concern with the four regions is that the primary season is packed too tight. Here's what I dub the Five Regions Primary Plan. It does eliminate New Hampshire's and Iowa's standing. States are divided into 5 regions that rotate the order each 4 years. Territories that don't vote in the presidential general election but do send delegates to the party convention are split between two of the regions.

Regions would rotate every for years. States within the first region could choose primary/caucus dates within the month of February. The second region in March, third in April, fourth in May, and fifth in June. The parties would hold their conventions between July 15 and August 15. A bipartisan commission in the same spirit as the presidential debate commission would be appointed to adjust the regions following the census to keep them roughly equal in population/congressional districts and to play traffic cop on party convention date and host city conflicts.

The way that small states are respected is that they have the freedom in setting their own primary dates within the month. For example, I doubt any state in Region 1 would hold their primary the same date as California. By going before or after, they can stick out. Particularly on the year the region is first, small states can play a key role in winnowing down candidates; just probably not to the same degree as New Hampshire and Iowa have traditionally done. And that is a good thing.

Click on the region for details. Click on the link below for a larger map.


View Larger Map

As always, comments welcome!

Friday, April 11, 2008

Making mountains out of molehills

It is the presidential election after all. It's time to make mountains out of molehills! (Or children into monkeys...)

She complains to her neighbors about their children climbing in the tree, which she sees as dangerous. She tells the father "the tree is not there for them to be climbing in there like monkeys." The mother calls the police, she gets a $75 ticket, and is now resigning as a delegate to the national convention because she has been labeled a racist.

Referring to children of another race climbing in a tree as monkeys is apparently verboten.

Pawlenty irritates Coleman

The A-P tells us that Republican Senator Norm Coleman has expressed disappointment over Pawlenty's line item veto of Central Corridor light-rail funds this week.

Normally, I'm pretty cynical about anything Coleman does. Especially in an election year. Mr. Votes-the-Republican-Line is trying to be seen as an independent and moderate voice for this November. Most of his actions should be viewed through that lens.

But I don't think his light, but helpful, criticism of the governor is for his own personal political objectives. I would say it is genuine. Certainly, there are other Republicans Coleman can publicly disagree with in order to be seen as independent minded. Expressing disagreements with the most popular, and influential, Republican in Minnesota probably doesn't help politically. So, good for him.

Random history

On this day in 1908, Carl Jung wrote a letter to his colleague Sigmund Freud.

What did the eminent psychologist have to say to the other eminent psychologist? Mainly, that he had a bout with the flu and was "too dissociated" to write much more. Clearly, a momentous day in history.

Freud, Jung, and fellow analytic psychologists

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Expelled Intelligence

Soon, Ben Stein's new "documentary" on intelligent design, Expelled, will hit theaters across the country. Over the past weeks, pre-release screenings have been shown across the country in order to drum up grassroots support for the controversial film.

Some people with scientific backgrounds have been able to see the film. The staff at Scientific American were treated to a private screening in their office. Minnesota biology professor, P.Z. Myers, who was also an unwitting guest in the film, was kicked out of a screening at the Mall of America. His guests, family members and friend Richard Dawkins were allowed to stay for some reason. Dawkins was also an unwitting interview subject in the film and is the most famous (or infamous) evolutionary biologist in the world today. Dawkins wrote about the experience in an essay called "Lying for Jesus."

The initial reports and reviews aren't encouraging. It appears the film spends little time actually defining evolutionary theory or even intelligent design. They do everything they can to connect evolutionary science to Nazi ideology and atrocities. Ben Stein actually appears at Nazi death camps in the film to underscore the point. The film gets its title from the notion that academics who have the audacity to question evolutionary theory and inquire into intelligent design get expelled from their jobs and profession. Some in the science community have begun to gather evidence that questions whether these are really intelligent design "martyrs."

Several of the scientists interviewed describe being bamboozled into participating in the film. A front company to the Canadian parent film company was presented to them. They were told the name of the film was something more balanced, despite the recent discovery that the domain name expelledthemovie.com was registered even before the interviews were conducted. So it's unlikely that the producers changed the name and focus of the film halfway through.

Dawkins and Myers discuss their film experience and impressions

Namecalling in politics

I think there is not enough substance in politics and too much name calling. Just turn on the television or radio, and name calling is what you hear. It's unhelpful and immature.

I generally try to refrain from name calling. Even those who deserve it. This week, my resolve has been tested. lI've resisted two days, but I can't any longer.

Tim Pawlenty is a dick.

On the radio: The McDonald sisters

Minnesota Public Radio ran a segment named something that wouldn't normally get my attention: Voices of Minnesota: Religion and Social Justice.

Blah... blah... blah...

But I happened upon it by turning on the radio and hearing a familiar voice talking about women and the church. The McDonald sisters were being interviewed!

Rita, Brigid, Kate and Jane McDonald are four sisters who grew up on a Minnesota farm and all became Catholic nuns. Each have devoted a lifetime to social justice work. And they've all been visible in the anti-war community in Minnesota. It is hard to have attended more than a few anti-war demonstrations in the Twin Cities and not have encountered one or more of the sisters.

As a former Catholic, it was surprising and refreshing to hear a Catholic nun say that she didn't put stock in the notion of original sin and that Jesus' role wasn't to die for our sins. What? I had always been taught in Catholic school that that was a key point.

The McDonald sisters are inspiring whether or not your religious views correspond with theirs. (Mine certainly don't.) Their interview on their faith and work is the first half of the program.

Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Fightin' Joe fights himself

Way back in 2006 Ned Lamont successfully challenged incumbent Joe Lieberman in the Democratic primary for the Connecticut Senate seat. Lieberman went on to run in the general election as an independent and won the three-way race with 52% of the vote.

The day before the August primary, the Lieberman campaign's website crashed. They blamed the Lamont campaign and their supporters for a "hack attack" and asked for a criminal investigation. They got a bunch of media out of it.

Guess what? The Stamford Advocate has learned the real story. A criminal investigation did ensue and discovered quite quickly that the website crash was the result of a badly configured server designed only to handle 100 emails an hour. An FBI memo dated BEFORE the 2006 general election stated their findings quite clearly. And yet, a Lieberman representative was still pointing fingers at the Lamont people in December. (Lieberman ain't just a sore loser, he's a sore winner too!)

Why are we finding this out a year and a half later? It's because the government authorities finally responded to a Freedom of Information Request filed in late 2006. Clearly the Lieberman people would have been told this at the time the investigation was closed in October 2006, but Senator Virtue himself hasn't come clean about making this mistaken allegation at a key moment of the nasty campaign. I think it's safe to say that Lieberman values playing the victim more than he values honesty.

Politicians often invent straw man arguments. Joe Lieberman makes himself the victim to his aggressor self.

It's this kind of thing that makes me actually hope McCain would pick Lieberman as his running mate. He'd elicit many opportunities to take him down. Playing the victim in this way doesn't play well in the race for the White House.

Song for Wednesday

I love Kristin Hersh's raspy, spooky voice. Here's one of her songs from the album Learn To Sing Like A Star, released last year.

In Shock