Showing posts with label University of St. Thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label University of St. Thomas. Show all posts

Friday, May 2, 2008

"Balancing" at St. Thomas

What is up with the University of St. Thomas? The St. Paul Catholic institution just can't seem to stop making bad news for itself as it makes interesting interpretations on how to retain a Catholic identity but respect freedom of thought. Their conclusion seems to be that you can't be Catholic and respect freedom of thought.

It's only been three weeks since the last incident, but this week the dean of the St. Thomas law school declared that a student could not get credit for the school's community service requirement when they were volunteering to help out with STD/STI and cancer screening, because it was at the evil Planned Parenthood.

The service approval process is governed by a student committee that had indeed approved the student's project at Planned Parenthood. Dean Thomas Mengler simply over-rode it. This is another trend at St. Thomas, give students authority to make decisions surrounding their academic experience, but over-rule them whenever they make decisions you don't like. It's very patronizing.

It's like the time when I was eight years old and my mom asked if I wanted to take a bath. I said no. And then she told me that I needed to take a bath anyways. It's just like that.

What's the point of being permissive in the first place if you're just going to butt in at your fancy?

The best part of the Star Tribune article on the matter is the very end:

Mengler, who issued his letter after receiving complaints from faculty, students and alumni, said Thursday he plans to meet with Borton soon, but he's not changing his mind.

"My decision is final," he said

This is great because, first, it implies that he made the initial decision without any dialog with the student (which would be a jerky thing to do); second, he is taking the George W. Bush approach to conflict resolution,* that is: You can feel free to talk to me, but it's not like I'm going to listen or it's going to matter at all.

The article notes this is part of the "latest philosophical wrestling match" on "the school's attempts to balance religious and academic values." (Emphasis mine.) We can't really say that the school is trying to "balance" Catholic values and scholarship. It's pretty clear that the school is an arm of the Catholic moral police first and foremost and not a place that values democracy or freedom of thought or speech.

* The George W. Bush method is a variation of the Dick Cheney method. Cheney, when facing conflict, will simply tell you to "fuck yourself." Bush's method is to tell critics to fuck off, without actually using the words "fuck off."

Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Priorities

Exhibit 1: University of St. Thomas invites, disinvites, then after dithering around and demoting a professor, they decide to reinvite Nobel Peace Prize laureate Archbishop Desmond Tutu. He declines their final invite.

Exhibit 2: The student government decides not to invite and fund an anti-abortion speaker nominated by a group of conservative students. The St. Thomas administration swiftly steps in and invites and pays for the speaker, because they know better than their students.

Why? Because they were concerned that the students' decision had "diminished the university's position on pro-life issues."

The University of St. Thomas, an academic institution, has demonstrated it is more important to display their pro-life cred than respect student-made decisions on speakers or to host a Nobel laureate to discuss world peace.